Masterlist!
More detailed TWs are marked chapter-by-chapter/story-by-story on Ao3. Stories containing them are marked here with a carrot (^). Stories containing NSFW/NSFT chapters are marked with a star (*).
A note: I’m going to be studying for my professional licensing exam soon, so this may be it for now.
Midnight Mass(terlist):
One Shots (pt 1)
One Shots (pt 2)
Yes, Paul & Grace have a Playlist
Paul & Grace Things People Have Made Me
My post about the real Crockett Island
My analysis of what all the numbers mean
Father Paul/Monsignor Pruitt SFW Alphabet
Haunted & Holy^* - Paul meets his own personal miracle while Crockett Island is falling apart. (Complete)
Holy & Free^* - a lot of pain but with a happier ending. (Complete)
The Ghost On the Shore^ - When Grace’s ex-husband shows up on Crockett, Paul will do anything to protect her. Anything. (Complete)
The Devil’s Resting Place^* - The Devil comes to Crockett Island in the form of an unassuming nun sent from the diocese to keep an eye on the married priest and his pregnant wife. As expected, everything goes terribly wrong. AHS/MM crossover! (Complete)
Tell Me Your Secrets:
Red Flags & Long Nights^* - She was sent to hunt down the Big Bad Wolf, but now here she is, helping him plan his escape. As they head out into the unknown, John can’t help but tread into territory he’s almost never been in. (Complete).
Upcoming Chapters (Midnight Mass):
Trivia Night - In which Paul rocks the religion category and has zero idea about popular culture
21st Century Vampire - when the twins turn 18, Paul & Grace finally tell them the truth
Rewrite the Stars - the carnival comes to Crockett Island
Make Me Melt* - Paul + Grace + a bottle of chocolate syrup…
Just Another Regret - Paul wishes he could’ve been there for Sarah while she was growing up
Another Day of Sun - Paul & Grace go for a sweet little date during a Crockett Island summer
Seven Minutes in Heaven* - the prequel to “People Will Talk”, aka “What happened in the confessional?”
Morning Has Broken* - “Did you have a good dream, Father?” // “Uh…” // “Do you want some help with that?”
The Three Wise Men* - Paul goes around the island asking his friends for first time advice
A Miracle Cure* - “I, umm, I’ve heard it helps with headaches…”
Rest Stop* - car sex request!
Exposure Therapy* - Paul wants to conquer his fear of blood in one context and one context only…
[still thinking of a title]* - “Confess your sins, Father.”





























































